Yoorrook Justice Commission Walk for Truth

Yoorrook Deputy Chair Commissioner Travis Lovett, Kerrupmara  and Gunditjmara man, had the vision and conviction to walk from Portland, where colonisation began, to Parliament in Melbourne. There the Yoorrook final report will then be handed to the Victorian government.

He is walking now, alongside local First Nations people and others, who have joined the walk at various stages. As the Commission stated:

“The walk will be a powerful way to build shared understanding of these truths, talking together about our history, while walking together to transform our future. For First Peoples and for all Victorians.

https://yoorrookjusticecommission.org.au/events/walkfortruth/

Two FOBIF committee members joined the walk on day 1 and day 2 at Portland. We arrived at the ‘convincing grounds’ at the end of day 1, the site of Victoria’s first recorded massacre of First Nations people. The second day, we visited Tae Rak Aquaculture centre and the UNESCO world heritage listed Budj Bim cultural landscapes. Stories were share by local First Nations people, stories of past, present and future aspirations.  

As Victoria’s first formal truth-telling process, over the past four years, Yoorrook has heard powerful truths from people right across the state, giving evidence on the impacts of colonisation, including systemic injustice, as well as the strength, resistance and achievements of First Peoples. These truths form the basis of Yoorrook’s final reports, documenting the past and providing a roadmap to transform the future. The final report will be handed to the State Government at Parliament House on the final day of the walk, June 18. We urge anyone who is able, to join these walks & events. It is a meaningful way we can support our First Nations people and the movement towards Treaty.

The Convincing Grounds, Portland Victoria

 

Posted in First Nations, News | Leave a comment

My introduction to Galk-galk Dhelkunya forest gardening

My name is Chrissi, and I am a committee member with the Friends of Box-Iron Bark Forests. As someone who works as a conservation ecologist, but is new to living on Dja Dja Wurrung Country, I am aware of how little I know and how much I must learn about the cultural and ecological history of this place. On a chilly morning in mid-May, I was lucky enough to nab a spot at a collaborative event hosted by Connecting Country and Dja Dja Wurrung. It consisted of talks, conversations and a site tour, exploring some of the forest gardening practices outlined in DJAARA’s Galk-galk Dhelkunya Forest Gardening Strategy. The following is a small highlight of what I took away from the amazingly informative morning plus some extra curricula reading of the strategy.  

The morning began with a Welcome to Country and Smoking Ceremony by Dja Dja Wurrung elder Uncle Rick Nelson who emphasized that “everyone is needed to heal country”. As a non-Indigenous person with English, Irish and North American heritage I find it a welcome reminder of the importance of the magnitude of restorative work there is to do, particularly in a landscape that has been so heavily impacted by colonial practices that had little respect for the rich ecological and cultural heritage.

After being welcomed onto Djaara Country we all funneled back inside for a presentation by DJAARA employee and Galk-galk Dhelkunya forest gardening project manager, Oli Moraes.

The Galk-galk Dhelkunya (translated too to care, to heal trees and forests) is “Djaara’s contemporary philosophy and practice of managing Djandak’s (Dja Dja Wurrung Country) cultural landscapes” [1]. The strategy is “guided by Dja Dja Wurrung cultural Lore and obligations. Djaara’s connection to Country, cultural rights and obligation have never ceased, nor was sovereignty ever ceded”[2]. The strategy doesn’t shy away from the challenges of incorporating cultural land management practices across a wide variety of tenure types, but it also provides clear guidance and a generous opportunity for non-Djaara land managers to support Djaara priorities.

Oli’s presentation highlighted the ways in which Dja Dja Wurrung Country still bears the scars of relatively recent destructive practices such as gold mining and intensive forestry.

One key historical legacy that Djaara is tackling with the forest gardening practices is the overabundance of galka (trees) across a range of forest types on Djaara country. Too many trees may seem like a strange problem for those not embedded in the world of conservation land management, but an overabundance of trees in some forest types can have negative ecological and cultural consequences. Forests with too many trees (compared to what’s normal for healthy mature forests of that type) can block sunlight from reaching the ground. This can stop smaller plants from growing and reduce the variety of habitats available in the forest. An overabundance of trees also increases the competition for sunlight and nutrients, which can cause trees to grow skinnier and straighter than they would if they were in a less competitive environment. While tall straight trees can be useful for timber harvesting (and are natural in some forests), in other forest types, tall skinny straight trees reduce the understory biodiversity and reduce the likelihood that trees will form large limbs which over decades can naturally break off leaving behind tree hollows. Ecologically, large hollow bearing trees are critically habitat for species such as sugar gliders and brush-tailed phascogales who rely on hollows for their homes. On a small scale, a patch of dense trees provides its own unique habitat, however wide spread clearing and logging across the region has resulted in an abundance of forests with overabundant dense straight trees and a relative dearth of sparse large hollow bearing trees.

Cultural thinning is a culturally responsive method based on the scientific principle of ecological thinning. This involves selectively removing some trees to reduce the overall competition for resources and improve the growth rate of the surviving trees. In some forest types, thinning occurs naturally over time; ecological thinning accelerates this process to help create a healthier, more resilient ecosystem that can support a greater diversity of plant and animal life. Like ecological thinning, cultural thinning involves “selectively removing galka in overly dense spaces” for ecological and community benefits however, cultural thinning has the additional elements of “reaping cultural outcomes such as increased space for older galka to thrive and utilisation of thinned product for tools and artifacts.”[3]

We were able to view some of the recent outcomes of cultural thinning during the tour of a patch of the Wombat Forest in Leonards Hill that is comanaged by DJAARA. The patch was a messmate stringybark (Eucalyptus obliqua) and candlebark (Eucalyptus rubida) dominated forests with a scattering of narrow-leaf and broad-leaf peppermints (Eucalyptus radiata and E. dives ), blackwoods (Acacia melanoxylon) and silver wattles (Acacia dealbata). The forest had been regularly harvested by Forestry Victoria up until the 1990’s utilizing a mix of forest harvesting techniques. One third of the site had been clear-felled (all trees removed) with the other two thirds having been selectively logged with some larger trees left as seed trees. To heal Country Djaara have been combining cultural methods with ecological sciences to understand the landscape from multiple perspectives. In studies of the site, the clear-felled area had an average of 2000 tree stems per hectare and in the selectively logged patch there was on average 1000 tree per hectare. A mature patch of this forest type should have around 20 large trees per hectare. If the forest was left to naturally mature (and in the absence of any large-scale fire or other disturbance event) the forest would likely naturally self-thin but this could take hundreds of years.

A key distinction between the ecological practice of thinning and the cultural practice of thinning is not only the expanded cultural outcomes, but the on-ground approach to thinning. Rather than the scientific outcome, of a strict number of stems per hectare, Djaara’s approach to thinning takes a distinct approach, part of which is based on what feels culturally right and what is culturally desired for the landscape.

As we walked around the culturally thinned forest, Oli highlighted that the thinned trees presented as much of a problem as an opportunity and there was no easy fix as to what to do with all the wood. The current approach is a blend of scientific, cultural and trial and error. In some patches trees have been ringbarked to kill the tree but the dead stems are left to naturally fall over. In other patches trees have been felled, but timber is left on the forest floor. Elsewhere, trees have been cut down and the timber has been removed off site. Oli highlighted that where timber was removed, it is not Djaara’s intention to make any money out of the harvesting and that the wood was not quality firewood, however some pieces of timber are utilised by the on-ground crew for cultural and creative practices. Across the different techniques the Djaara are returning to the site to observe the different ecological responses.

Cultural thinning is only one of the practices that are outlined in Galk-galk Dhelkunya forest gardening but it was the practice we explored in the most detail during the tour. Other techniques include Djandak Wi (cultural fire practices), revegetation and rehabilitation of Djandak where vegetation has been removed, regenerative practices and partnerships across Djandak and practices to protect gatjin (water) across the landscape[4].

Restoring balance to the landscape, both ecologically and culturally, is a core element of all the practices in the Galk-galk Dhelkunya forest gardening project. “If you don’t have all the elements of the ecosystem including Djaara, things are out of balance” shared Oli.

The morning left me feeling lucky to have access to such a generous sharing of knowledge so early into my time living and working on Djaara Country and hopeful for future scientific and cultural collaboration.

 

 

[1] Page 16 of Galk-galk Dhelkunya Forest Gardening Strategy 2022-2034.

[2] Page 7 of Galk-galk Dhelkunya Forest Gardening Strategy 2022-2034.

[3] Page 31 of Galk-galk Dhelkunya Forest Gardening Strategy 2022-2034.

[4] Pages 31 – 35 of Galk-galk Dhelkunya Forest Gardening Strategy 2022-2034.

Oli standing amongst a patch of culturally thinned forest where the timber. Photo: Chrissi Charles

Oli introducing us to the site, photo: Chrissi Charles

An example of a recently ring barked tree where the stem has been left in the landscape, photo: Chrissi Charles

Posted in First Nations, Nature Observations, News | 1 Comment

FOBIF June 15th walks: the long and the short

FOBIF is offering a choice this month. Here are the details:

Long Walk: Mount Alexander

We will start walking from Old Koala Park and do an anti-clockwise circuit of about 12.3 km. A bit over half of this is off track in typical Mt Alexander type terrain. Note that this walk will leave the Community House at 9am.

Apart from undulations there are two significant climbs. The first is 160m up a spur from Whisky Gully to a lovely flat plateau which we then follow gently downhill all the way to meet Aqueduct Creek. There is also a side trip to an interesting rock cave and some large old trees along here.

The second is 270m of sustained climbing up another spur to the towers. It is quite steep and taxing, especially near the top where we will be rewarded with another interesting rock cave to visit.

To complete the circuit we follow the Goldfields Track via Dog Rocks back to the cars.

At a comfortable pace, the circuit should take about 5 hours plus breaks.

Because of the climbs it is a good solid day out requiring a little bit of fitness. In the unlikely event of weather conditions being very bad, there are some possibilities to shorten the circuit.

Enquiries: Jeremy Holland 0409 933 046

Short walk: Heroic Moss!

This more leisurely option starts at the Community House at the usual time of 9.30 am.

Here’s a chance to get a look at some of the micro miracles of the bush, mosses, which seem capable of surviving impossibly hard conditions. Welcome rain has added interest to this 2 km walk. It will focus on getting a look at a good sample of the mosses of the region, with maybe a few lichens thrown in. We’ll explore a ruined waterway near White Gum track, checking out the impressive number of mosses which have hung in through the long dry, colonising the most unlikely of places, bullet riddled cars! Great rock walls! World Heritage Erosion!

We’ll supply hand lenses and copies of FOBIF’s moss guide, but if you have your own, bring them along.

Enquiries: Cassia Read 0432357191 or Bernard Slattery 0499 624 160

Posted in News, Walks | Leave a comment

Membership reminder

Thanks to everyone who has paid their membership fees.

In case it has slipped your mind or are a new member, you can find the relevant form here.

Members who haven’t changed their details can skip filling out the form and deposit their subscription directly in the FOBIF bank account:

BSB 633000 Account number 108508086.

Please include your surname/s as the reference. 

Posted in News | Leave a comment

New FOBIF supported book on gravel bike rides

Maldon Cycling, with support from FOBIF, has produced a new book, Seventeen Gravel Bike Rides: Maldon & Beyond. 

The area around Maldon is a great place for gravel rides on unmade roads and tracks. The routes are through local bush and farming land around Maldon, to Newstead, Castlemaine and Cairn Curran Reservoir. A number of rides are in the Maldon Historic Reserve and the Muckleford State Forest, which have networks of interesting tracks.

The book contains ten maps by Jase Haysom showing seventeen routes and is generously illustrated with photos by Bronwyn Silver, Ian McKelvie, Bernard Slattery, and Geoff Park. Bernard has also contributed a short essay, ‘This country is worth a good look!’. Sample  pages from the book can be found here and here

Rosalie Hastwell, the councillor for Maldon & surrounds, will launch the book at Maldon Neighbourhood Centre (corner Church and Edwards Streets, Maldon) at 11 am on Sunday 15 June.

Light refreshments will be served. If you would like to attend, please let Maldon Cycling know for catering purposes. Their email address is maldoncycling@gmail.com 

We will provide information about where to buy the book and the price in a future post.

Posted in News | Leave a comment

Alchemy of gold 1: Transformation into what?

The Alchemy of Gold, an event bringing together ‘experts, historians and the community to explore how the discovery of gold in the 1850s reshaped Victoria economically, socially and politically’ took place over the weekend of May 16-18. Its aim: ‘celebrate our goldfields heritage’.

The context of the event is the ambitious project to achieve World Heritage status for the Victorian goldfields.

You only have to look at the above list of topics to realise that the title, ‘alchemy of gold’, and the aim, to ‘celebrate our goldfields heritage’, were contentious. From the beginning of the weekend, it was acknowledged that not everything in that era was to be celebrated: gold rushes worldwide have all been accompanied by dispossession of indigenous peoples; and the environmental destruction that accompanied Victoria’s rush was eloquently evoked during the event [see below].

The negative effects of the age of gold haven’t conveniently disappeared into the past, and a simple ‘celebration’ would run the risk of looking like a whitewash. This is particularly problematic when you consider the tendency of heritage experts to ignore or downplay the negative experiences of the past. And a World Heritage Listing, if improperly defined, could worsen the situation by solidifying the notion that the gold rush was all romanticism, grit and colourful drama (to be remembered over a nice cup of coffee).

So: how did Alchemy of Gold go? Like all events in which there were numerous speakers (well over thirty, in this case), it was a mixed bag. Beautifully organised, smoothly run: but leaving us with difficult questions.

Posted in News | 2 Comments

Alchemy 2: should the ‘new golden age’ be like the last one?

One question inevitably arising in such an event is: how have the events of the gold rush shaped the society and place we live in now? The answers are familiar: egalitarianism, a cosmopolitan society, democracy…but one feature of our society which usually doesn’t make this list is: a tendency to exploit nature without heed for the future.

With influential observers touting a ‘new golden age’ in Victoria, it’s important to avoid repeating past mistakes: and we know that some of the less desirable practices of the gold rush have not disappeared.   The Victorian Auditor General reported in 2020 that many current or recent mining and quarry sites ‘have been poorly rehabilitated or not treated at all. If not addressed, these sites also present risks to Victorians and the environment.’ The estimated cost to the taxpayer of fixing this was at the time $361 million or more.

Currently the state government is considering a proposal to increase fees payable by mining companies for rehabilitation by 234%, because ‘commissioned independent analysis in 2022 indicated that fees recovered from the resources sector do not cover the costs of regulating it.’ [A consultation on this proposal is open now on Engage Victoria. Curiously, this consultation seems to have the aim of figuring whether the proposal is good for business or not. It doesn’t ask whether the idea is good for the environment, or the public. You might want to check the consultation out here. It closes on June 23].

The question arising out of all this is: which practices in our gold rush heritage do we want to celebrate and promote, and which ones do we want to soberly assess and avoid repeating?

Posted in News | Leave a comment

Alchemy 3: repairing the mistakes of the past

There were some very good presentations at the weekend’s event, but we’ll focus on one theme only: environmental history. Standout speakers here included Susan Lawrence, co author of Sludge– disaster on Victorian Goldfields (a book which should be compulsory reading for all heritage buffs), and local ecologist Paul Foreman. Paul’s presentation began bluntly:

‘…It is timely to reflect on the Gold Rush’s full legacy – not just the claim that the Victorian goldfields were the cradle of modern Australia economically (i.e. wealth generation) and culturally (i.e. mass global immigration, in part the origin of the Australian ‘fair go’ and so on), but also that the gold rush “obliterated” the natural environment (ECC 1997) and further entrenched Aboriginal dispossession, vilification and oppression (Cahir 2012). Now I should say the word “obliterated” is not my words – it’s a direct quote from a systematic environmental assessment by a Government Statutory Authority in the 1990’s). Even if it is a given that people accepted these sorts of consequences as an inevitable price to pay on the frontier and indeed today, it is also true that the full impacts remain largely misunderstood and/or ignored.’

After documenting the damage referred to above, Paul ended on a positive note, which we believe should underpin any World Heritage bid:

‘I think it is important not to gloss over the less savoury and inconvenient short and long term environmental and cultural impacts of a the Gold Rush; a seismic event that unleashed global humanity on an unsuspecting traditional society and delicate Gondwanan ecosystems with little understanding, consideration or constraint.

‘Accordingly, if we have learnt anything from history, the concept of redress (indeed justice) should become central to the World Heritage bid; not just an add on or rhetoric. (FOBIF emphasis)

‘Continuing to ignore these impacts – and in fact continuing to see them as an intractable part of the ‘historic fabric’ of the landscape – should no longer be an acceptable or prudent perspective.

‘Today we have the knowledge and wherewithal to act to address these crises, both because it is the right thing to do, but perhaps more importantly, because it would finally be in line with the vision of ‘forever’ that, if we are honest, we all take for granted but know in our hearts is really in jeopardy.

‘Thus it behoves us – this generation – to act!

‘The future of course isn’t set in stone so we have an opportunity to create a new trajectory of recovery for the Box Ironbark Forests and Woodlands so severely impacted by the Gold Rush.

‘Arguably restoration should have commenced a long time ago, but it’s never too late..   Consequently, I would like to call for a campaign to leverage resourcing on the back of the World Heritage bid to further develop and scale up effective landscape restoration solutions that complement the bid’s  broader aims.

‘I think the World Heritage bid represents a great opportunity to build a more positive environmental legacy from here on. . One that is completely in line with the primary aims of awareness, education and thriving regional communities and towns. I look forward to the discussions, collaborations and transformative (indeed healing) actions ahead.’

Posted in News | 1 Comment

Fire in the Maldon Historic Reserve

Forest Fire Management burned a biodiversity rich section of the Maldon Historic Reserve, near the Railway Track, on May 9. Conditions were described as ‘ideal’, with no wind, and appropriate moisture levels.

Readers will remember we have reported on this fire proposal before—see our posts with links to a map of the site here

The Department’s aim was a low intensity burn to remove 4cm of ground fuel and prevent elevated bushfire hazards. A preburn fire was lit to create smoke so that small animals could get away. Three exclusion zones were created to protect nominated plant species.

In the burn zone: no large habitat trees seem to have been destroyed; but in an area dominated by spindly regrowth eucalypts, the loss of even medium sized trees is to be regretted.

Local environmentalists met with fire management both before and after ignition, and a further onsite meeting is planned for about 8 weeks time.

The fire was described by fire officers as low intensity; staff and students of Melbourne University had placed probes around the site to measure heat levels. In fact, the fire intensity varied widely, with some areas severely burned and others barely touched, achieving a mosaic effect around the site….but managers are considering returning to the untouched areas for another go.

There’s no doubt that managers are making serious efforts to reconcile environmental concerns and current ideas about fire danger. In the present case, the exercise seems to have been pulled off without bringing down any large habitat trees, a significant improvement on past exercises; yet a number of medium sized trees was destroyed—a regrettable result. Though this area is rich in understorey and ground cover plants and orchids, the tree cover is largely spindly regrowth eucalypts, and can ill afford loss of trees of good size.

As we’ve said before, moreover, there’s an apparently irreconcilable clash of views when it comes to that 4 cm of leaf litter: does it constitute a ‘very high to extreme fuel hazard’ (Fuel Hazard Assessment Guide), or is it a precious environmental asset? According to Arthur Rylah research, ‘litter plays an important role in nutrient cycling, and provides important habitat for invertebrates and small vertebrates. Frequent burning (for example, 3-5 year intervals) will disrupt natural processes in the short-term and may eventually lead to a depletion of soil nutrients and loss of habitat.’

Exercises like the one under discussion are in fact experiments. Part of their value depends on what kind of monitoring and research is done before and after them—and as we know, there’s little or no credible research arising from many such burns. As the Auditor General put it in 2021, ‘DELWP cannot demonstrate if, or how well, it is halting further decline in Victoria’s threatened species populations.’

 

Posted in News | 2 Comments

Pre-1852 Eucalypts of Maldon Walk

Today’s FOBIF walk was in the Maldon township on a chilly, windy morning. We are grateful to Bev Phillips from MULGA ( Maldon Urban Landcare Group) for her informative and interesting talks, as we walked and gazed in wonder at the ancient trees. We now might be able to tell the difference between Grey Box, Yellow Box, Red Box and Long-leaved box trees, but as Bev kept reminding us, don’t just rely on the bark to identify a tree! (Bev acknowledged Frances Cincotta for that point of emphasis).  Specimen samples of some of the trees were provided so we could look closely at the leaf shape and fruit. It was a wonderful walk seeing the 500 year old tree and some of  the 300 & 200 year old trees, all catalogued on private and public land and being protected by MULGA.

Thanks to Linda Hickey for this contribution.

Posted in Nature Observations, Walks | Leave a comment